Banc One Partners Split To Form New LBO Firm
One result of the planned consolidation between Banc One Capital and Banc One Venture Corp. is the departure of some Banc One Venture partners to start their own buyout fund, with the blessing of their former bosses.
H. Wayne Foreman, Robert L. Cook, Jr., and Daniel J. Jagla on Jan. 1 resigned from Banc One Corp. and launched Cedar Creek Partners LLC.
"This was a negotiated parting," said Mr. Foreman. "Banc One was going through the consolidation, and we proposed that in lieu of being consolidated with Banc One Capital, we create Cedar Creek."
Banc One agreed and, in turn, said it would commit capital amounting to as much as 25% of the firm's new fund, called Cedar Creek Partners of Wisconsin L.P., which was launched at the time of the partners resignation. The fund has a target between $50 million and $80 million. To date, Banc One has committed $15 million.
Mr. Foreman added Banc One has not yet agreed to invest in future funds.
A second investor already on board is Heller Financial, which has committed $3 million, Mr. Foreman said.
On completion of fund raising, which is expected to end June 30, Cedar Creek will invest in management buyouts of privately held companies. Based on the expected capitalization of the limited partnership, Cedar Creek will be able to invest as much as $10 million per transaction, Mr. Foreman said.
For the time being, Cedar Creek still will manage assets of Banc One Venture Corp.
-T.B.
Return to index of news articles
CEDAR CREEK PARTNERS LLC, MILWAUKEE, aims to raise $50 million to $80 million for Cedar Creek Partners of Wisconsin, L.P. Cedar Creek was formed last month by H. Wayne Foreman, Robert L. Cook Jr. and Daniel J. Jagla, previously the senior management of Banc One Venture Corp., Milwaukee. Banc One Corp., Columbus, OH, is consolidating Banc One Venture, a wholly owned subsidiary and SBIC, into Banc One Capital Partners, L.P., a separate SBIC based in Columbus. The parting was amicable, however, and Banc One intends to invest up to $15 million into Cedar Creek. The three Cedar Creek partners also will help manage the nine companies remaining in Banc One Venture's portfolio. Cedar Creek intends to invest in management buyouts, recapitalizations and acquisitions of privately held companies. Reach the partners at (414) 272-5500.
Return to index of news articles
CEDAR CREEK PARTNERS LLC, MILWAUKEE, reaches a $60 million first closing on its debut fund, Cedar Creek Partners, L.P., The firm expects to finish fund raising at its $80 million goal by the end of August. Limited partners in the buyout fund include BOCP Holdings Corp. (an affiliate of Banc One Corp.), Everen Securities, Inc., Heller Financial, Inc., Lubar & Company, PNC Equity Management, Provident Bancorp, Inc., The Harry & Lynde Bradley Foundation and S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc. Retirement Plan Trust. Reach Cedar Creek Partners at (414) 272-5500.
Return to index of news articles
Cedar Creek Rustles Up $60 Million First Closing
Cedar Creek Partners LLC on May 29 held a first closing on $60 million for its debut buyout fund, Cedar Creek Partners of Wisconsin L.P., said Dan Jagla, a partner at the Milwaukee, Wisc.-based firm.
The firm was founded in January by three partners who resigned from Banc One Capital following its merger with Banc One Venture Corp. (BUYOUTS Jan. 13, p. 3). Launched soon after the firm was formed, the fund features a target of between $50 million and $80 million and will be capped at the higher figure.
Limited partners committing to the closing include BOCP Holdings Corp., an affiliate of Banc One Corp, which committed approximately $15 million; Heller Financial, which committed $3 million; Everen Securities; Lubar & Co.; PNC Equity Management Corp.; Provident Bancorp.; The Harry & Lynde Bradley Foundation and S.C. Johnson & Son Retirement Plan Trust.
The fund will target buyouts and recapitalizations of privately held manufacturing, distribution and service companies valued between $ 10 million and $50 million. Cedar Creek expects to wrap fund raising by August.
-K. T.
Return to index of news articles
Cedar Creek Wraps Debut at $77 Million
Milwaukee, Wis.-based Cedar Creek Partners LLC at press time has scheduled a second and final closing on $17 million to take its debut fund to a final tally of $77 million, said Dan Jagla, a partner.
Cedar Creek Partners of Wisconsin L.P. was launched early this year with a target between $50 million and $80 million by several former partners of Banc One Venture Corp., who left following its merger with Banc One Capital (BUYOUTS Jan. 13, p. 3). Cedar Creek's partners continue to advise Banc One on investments in Banc One Venture's portfolio.
The fund landed a first closing on $60 million in May (BUYOUTS June 9, p. 8). It will target buyouts and recapitalizations of private manufacturing, distribution and service companies, principally those located in the Midwest, with valuations of less than $50 million.
The fund's limited partners include BOCP Holdings Corp., an affiliate of Banc One which committed approximately $15 million, Everen Capital Corp., First Bank, N.A., Heller Financial, Lubar Nominees, PNC Venture Corp., The Harry & Lynde Bradley Foundation, S.C. Johnson Retirement Plan Trust and clients of Abbott Capital Management.
-K.T.
Return to index of news articles
CEDAR CREEK PARTNERS, LLC, MILWAUKEE, closes its debut fund, Cedar Creek Partners, L.P., at $77 million. The new fund targets acquisitions and recapitalizations of companies valued at under $50 million, primarily in the Midwest. Limited partners include BOCP Holdings Corp., Everen Capital Corp., First Bank, N.A., Heller Financial, Inc., Lubar Nominees, PNC Venture Corp., The Harry & Lynde Bradley Foundation, Inc., S.C. Johnson & Son, Inc.'s Retirement Plan Trust, and clients of Abbott Capital Management, LLC. Cedar Creek was formed by the former management team of Banc One Venture Corp. The group continues to advise Banc One Corp. on the Banc One Venture portfolio. Reach Cedar Creek Partners at (414) 272-5500.
Return to Index of news articles
More Funds Choose a Midwest Focus
"For example, Cedar Creek Capital Partners LLC, which focuses on deals in the Wisconsin area, last fall wrapped its $77 million debut fund (BUYOUTS Oct. 27, 1997, p. 8)."
-J.K.
Return to index of news articles
"There are about 800 private equity partnerships, some giant multibillion funds run by grizzled veterans like Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co., Thomas H. Lee & Co. (FORBES, Nov. 17, 1997) and Forstmann Little & Co. (Forbes, Nov. 17, 1997). But the vast majority are small and anonymous, like New York-based Madison Investment Partners or Milwaukee's Cedar Creek Partners. The business is so hot today that even new funds without reliable track records are turning away money."
-Mathew Schifrin
Return to index of news articles
Two Add-Ons Fertilize Cedar Creek's Portfolio
Cedar Creek Partners acquired the nursery division of Pace International late last month as an add-on to the firm's Waupaca Northwoods platform.
The firm also acquired Universal Electric Sign Co. Inc., a neon sign maker in September, said Wayne Foreman, a Cedar Creek general partner.
Although he declined to disclose the individual purchase prices, Mr. Foreman said the aggregate acquisition price of the two companies was in excess of $20 million.
The Pace division deal was an asset purchase, whereby Pace retains both the receivables and liabilities of the division accrued up to the time of the transaction. This allowed Cedar Creek to acquire the division at about five times cash flow, Mr. Foreman said, adding this was a relative discount.
The nursery, based in Yakima, Wash., manufactures fertilizers for the lawn and garden industry and has $14 million in sales for 1997. The Waupaca, Wisconsin-based Waupaca Northwoods is supplier of garden supplies and custom soil blends for golf courses that Cedar Creek acquired in July.
In September, Cedar Creek acquired Maspeth, N.Y.-based Universal Electric. The company had more than $10 million in sales for the last fiscal year. Terms were not disclosed. Universal Electric was added to EPIK Corp., a holding company specializing in point-of-purchase displays.
Mr. Foreman said his firm is currently considering additional add-ons for both EPIK and Waupaca.
Cedar Creek also acquired a communications company late last month, the details of which Mr. Foreman declined to discuss.
Cedar Creek Partners was formed in January 1997 (BUYOUTS Jan. 13, 1997, p. 3) when Wayne Foreman, Robert Cook and Daniel Jagla left Banc One Corp. to form their own buyout firm.
-D.S.
Return to index of news articles
GREENSMIX DIVISION OF WAUPACA NORTHWOODS
Christine Faulks sees a lucrative shade of green when pondering recent demographic trends. The United States is home to 70 million gardeners. Their average age is 50. And 100,000 people are turning 50 on a daily basis. "What do you think those 50-year-olds are doing when they're not gardening?" the president of Greensmix in Waupaca says. "They're golfing. Anyone can play the game. You don't have to be good at it. You can just walk around and enjoy getting fresh air."
Greensmix is well positioned to capitalize on those trends. The firm, launched in 1986 as a subsidiary of Faulks Brothers Construction, is the nation's leading provider of "root zone mix," the soil used as the growing medium for greens, tees and sports turf. The typical 18-hole golf course may require 8,000 to 15,000 tons of root zone mix, which costs $25 or more per ton. "It takes a long time to build a reputation in this business," Faulks said. "What we do (with land) is what a pharmacist does with medication. A soil-testing laboratory gives the course builders a list of blend specifications and then the builders give it to us." In other words, the first green must perform identically to the last one. Water must percolate at precise rates. Rich color and healthy growth must remain consistent. "What we do is tremendously important," Faulks said. "If you had to rip that green out, the liability would be horrendous. "The fact is, golfers will know if the green is not performing. If it's very hard, if it has standing water, if the ball lands improperly - they'll see the negatives. They take the positives for granted."
Greensmix has worked on golf courses designed by professionals like Arnold Palmer, Jack Nicklaus, Robert Trent Jones II and Tom Fazio. Closer to home, it recently completed projects including Whistling Straits near Kohler, Thornberry Creek in Green Bay and Horseshoe Bay in Door County. Prospects for growth also remain positive: The United States is home to about 26.4 million golfers, 16,400 courses and continues to grow at about 7.5 percent annually. This year alone, about 1,000 courses were under construction and another 1,000 were in planning stages. Greensmix strives to be involved in about 25 percent of those projects, Faulks said. Few golf enthusiasts realize the extent of this specialty business nestled in northeast Wisconsin. "That's half the fun of it," Faulks said with a laugh. "People don't even know we're here."
Some jobs are more memorable than others, she added. During a project in Hawaii, for instance, the Greensmix crew had 27 hours to unload 7,000 tons of soil blend from an Australian freighter. If they did not clear the docking space within that time frame, the company would face severe demurrage penalties. "That was a memorable, thrilling experience," recalled Faulks, who also is the first female board member of the Golf Course Builders Association of America.
In recent years, Greensmix's parent company - Waupaca NorthWoods - has undergone a substantial transformation. In July 1998, Milwaukee's Cedar Creek Partners acquired the company for an undisclosed amount.
Waupaca NorthWoods' other divisions include Waupaca Materials and NorthWoods Organics, making it the Midwest's largest suppliers of packaged soils and manure for retail chains like Target, Wal-Mart, Menards and Fleet Farm. "We want to be the largest in the country," Faulks said. While the Faulks family appreciated the sentimental value of retaining the organics-materials operations, the sale came at a good time, she said. "It was like a raising a child. We grew (those divisions) and 11 years later, these were very, very serious companies. It was time for them to go to college," Faulks said. "It was a big emotional decision. But it was not like selling our name (associated with the 50-year-old construction company). "It took us a couple of years to realize that if we were going to take these businesses to the next step, we had to let them go."
Since then, Waupaca NorthWoods has moved aggressively to roll up other players. In November 1998, it acquired the retail lawn and garden lines of Pace Nursery Products, based in Bellevue, Wash. The acquisition included four plants in Berna Lillo, N.M.; Parker, Wash.; Nampa, Idaho; and Spearfish, S.D. In February, the company picked up Interlochen Corp.'s Landscape Division, encompassing operations in Sikeston, Mo., and Little Rock, Ark. The acquisitions have allowed the Waupaca company to grow its work force from 40 full-time and 40 seasonal workers to 150 full-time and 125 seasonal workers. While Waupaca NorthWoods would likely have pursued the buyouts regardless, the addition of Cedar Creek's monetary muscle "brought a strong financial partner into the process," Faulks said.
Earlier this month, Waupaca NorthWoods and Smith Garden
Products Inc. of Cumming, Ga., announced an agreement in principle to combine the
two companies. The decision probably will reach completion by the end of the year.
"We're likely to keep the Waupaca NorthWoods name, but incorporate
their brands into the fold," Faulks said, adding the combined assets will allow the
Waupaca side of the equation access into markets in Texas, Florida, Mississippi and
Georgia. That growth allows the company to stake strong market shares in products
appealing to both gardeners and golfers, Faulks said. "We're a year-round
operation," she said, noting November through February "we enter the repair
stage, working on equipment, repainting and getting ready for next spring."
By Avi Stern, Fox Valley Inc. Editor
Return to index of news articles
Cedar Creek Partners
Acquiring, Partnering and Recapitalizing
Editor's Comment: Over the past few years M&A Today has in terviewed numerous
private equity groups, each time in an effort to identify and elaborate on what the funds
do difterently from their peers and more importantly, why they are individually
successful. Our trip to Milwaukee to interview Cedar Creek Partners (CCP) was particularly
rewarding not only because the firm focuses on the "rust belt" of our country
but also because of its total approach.
Background
Cedar Creek Partners originated as an amicable spin-off from Banc One Venture
Corporation, a Milwaukee-based whollyowned subsidiary of Banc One Corporation. While
working as a team for over 10 years at Banc One, Wayne Foreman, Dan Jagla and Bob Cook
established a portfolio of 30 companies with over $1.1 billion in combined revenues. The
impetus for this executive management team to operate independent of Banc One was driven
basically by regulatory and strategic factors.
The Fund
Following lengthy negotiations, Messrs. Foreman, Jagla and Cook reached an agreement
with Banc One on December 31,1996. Under the agreement, they would form an independent
company yet continue to advise Banc One with respect to its remaining 10 portfolio
companies. Very importantly, they would continue to receive their sharing of the profits.
In addition, Banc One agreed to commit $15 million towards the formation of Cedar Creek
Partners' first limited partnership. Starting with the commitment from Banc One and a
significant amount of capital of their own, Cedar Creek Partners raised a total of $77
million from financial institutions, pension funds, charitable foundations and high net
worth individuals. Between the Banc One portfolio and the new partnership, Cedar Creek
Partners now has over $100 million under management.
The investment model targets low to medium tech companies with enterprise values between $10 and $50 million, with a minimum EBIT of $2 million. The structure of a Cedar Creek Partners' deal is typically comprised of 50% senior debt, 25% mezzanine capital and 25 % equity. They usually structure their transactions without contingencies such as earnouts. Their targeted internal rate of return (IRR) is in the range of 30 % to 35 %, but their track record has exceeded this return. One reason for exceeding their investment targets is that this management team has not recorded a realized loss in its last 21 investments dating back to 1990. Cedar Creek's preferred valuation method utilizes a Discounted Cash Flow approach. Since November 1997, Cedar Creek Partners' new partnership has acquired/recapitalized 7 new platform companies and funded 3 add-on acquisitions to those platforms. They have also funded one add-on acquisition for the Banc One portfolio.
Cedar Creek Partners is not a heavy user of seller financing or earnouts. They often
use their cash purchase price proposals as a negotiating advantage against competitive
buyers. They tend to use closing escrows to protect against quantifiable issues, such as
working capital calculations, or known matters of liability or impairments to the assets.
The Management Team
Management has recently committed to add Steve Peterson as the fourth owner of Cedar
Creek Partners LLC. Steve has been with Cedar Creek/Banc One since January 1994. While
this group averages only 40 years of age, the partners average about 14 years of private
equity management experience. Additionally, the firm has four other key players: Mike
Gandrud, VP (and a junior deal maker); Ellie Berg, V-P-Marketing; Becky Diedrich,
VP-Finance and Brian McDonald, an associate.
Differentiation
M&A Today pressed the management of Cedar Creek Partners to tell us why, as a
private equity group, they are special. Their answer: "We pull it all together."
The implication, after further explaining, is that Cedar Creek Partners does not sell
capital. With so many private equity firms around, capital is no longer the distinguishing
feature that it once was. Cedar Creek sells itself as a buying principal that has the
experience, track record and credibility to get the deal done. "We price, structure
and negotiate the transaction. Additionally, we conduct most of our own due diligence and
raise any necessary outside financing. We can work with an incumbent management team or
bring in outside expertise. We happen to have money too."
Capitalizing on Relationships
Cedar Creek Partners largely creates its own deal flow through its proprietary contact
base and business relationships. One such relationship led to the formation of EPIK
Corporation, a consolidator of point-of-purchase displays. One of Cedar Creek's contacts
referred Perry Ankerson, an executive with considerable experience in the industry, to
Wayne Foreman. After meeting with Perry, Cedar Creek agreed to support his consolidation
strategy within the industry. Cedar Creek announced this initiative to its contact base,
which then produced a considerable amount of leads and prospects. The effort has resulted
in two acquisitions so far, with several more under consideration. The first two companies
are:
Art Etc., Inc. from Louisville, Kentucky is a screen process printer that provides creative arts design, graphics printing production, and fulfillment services for advertising and promotional projects. The company is one of the top ten companies specializing in point-of-purchase displays in the United States. Art Etc. primarily serves convenience stores, fast food restaurants and advertising agencies.
Universal Electric Sign Co., Inc. is an international manufacturer of market specific indoor neon and outdoor identity signs located in Maspeth, New York. The company also has an operation in Dublin, Ireland which manufactures and distributes neon signs to the European market. Staffed with over 100 highly skilled glassblowers, Universal is one of the "Big 3" neon sign manufacturers worldwide. Some of Universal's customers are Arby's, Snapple, Barnes & Noble, Miller Beer and Whirlpool.
These opportunities were referred to Cedar Creek Partners not because they are just another private equity firm, but because they have formed a relationship with Mr. Ankerson and have organized a firm which is now recognized as a leading player in the point-of-purchase display industry.
Another example of a unique proprietary relationship is between Cedar Creek Partners
and Bruce Mommsen. While at Banc One Venture Corporation, the management of Cedar Creek
Partners had great success in backing Mommsen's company, Imperial Acquisition Corporation.
Imperial was a successful chain of sports apparel and footwear stores operating in both
strip malls and enclosed malls. After growing the company to over $50 million in revenue,
Mommsen sold Imperial to Just for Feet, Inc. Bruce solidified his relationship with Cedar
Creek's management team by investing part of his proceeds into their new partnership.
Later, Cedar Creek Partners approached Bruce about using the Cedar Creek contact base to
search for another retailer to buy. This joint effort resulted in the purchase of Noah's
Collectors Showcase, a retailer of collectables located in the Northeast.
Due Diligence
Cedar Creek Partners prides itself on its due diligence when consummating a
transaction. The firm conducts most of its due diligence itself and farms out only
specific limited tasks to outside consultants. They typically hire a nationally recognized
accounting firm to conduct financial due diligence and an environmental engineering firm
to assess environmental matters, but the business, management and marketing due diligence
is usually conducted internally. Cedar Creek Partners has found that it is particularly
important to conduct indepth market due diligence. One of the basic parts of the process
is to interview each of a company's major customers and a random sampling of the smaller
ones. They believe customers are best suited to opine on why a company is successful and
its prognosis for the future. Cedar Creek Partners requires superior performance in each
of the following areas: the company's importance to customers, the company's competitive
position within the industry, industry dynamics, integrity of management and analysis of
profitability.
Revealing Mistakes
M&A Today bluntly asked whether the management team has made any due diligence
mistakes. Wayne Foreman responded: "Through experience, we have learned that in
co-investment situations, we cannot rely on third parties to conduct our due diligence.
When we rely on ourselves for due diligence, we have no one else to blame. It is also
critical to discuss industry issues with knowledgeable outsiders in addition to operating
management teams. These outsiders often offer an interesting and unique perspective."
Conclusion
In the March 1998 issue of Forbes magazine ("LBO Madness"), Cedar Creek is
highlighted as one of a vast majority of "small and anonymous" equity
partnerships. Although, Cedar Creek may be small when compared to other funds within the
industry, the firm is in fact a well-known, reputable and successful buyout group focusing
on middle-market business acquisitions, consolidations and recapitalizations.
By Russ Robb, Editor-In-Chief, M&A Today
Return to index of news articles